March 31, 2023


Moving Forward

Can my employer legally change my contract from full-time to freelance?

THE Problem

Just one thirty day period ago, I started off a entire-time, everlasting task. Now they say they’re altering my agreement to be freelance, as desired, simply because of the economic downturn. The firm says they’re authorized to do this because I have not passed my probation time period. Do I have any rights in this circumstance?

THE Very first Respond to

Busayo A. Faderin, senior affiliate, Monkhouse Legislation Work Legal professionals, Toronto

At the time an staff and employer concur to employment terms and start an work romantic relationship, generating a modify to a elementary expression of that arrangement needs consent from both of those the employee and the employer. Normally, a unilateral change by an employer might probably be a constructive dismissal.

A constructive dismissal takes place when the employer demonstrates an intention to no for a longer time be sure by the work contract. A constructive dismissal can manifest in two methods:

  1. The employer breaches an specific or implied basic term of the employment agreement.
  2. The employer’s perform usually reveals that it meant not to be sure by the work contract.

In response to the employer’s unilateral breach, the worker has two selections. They may well either:

  1. Settle for the unilateral modify to their employment agreement. If the staff consents to or condones the transform, there is no breach of agreement and no constructive dismissal.
  2. Reject the unilateral and essential alter and allege constructive dismissal.

The worker has a sensible period of time of time to “try out” the new arrangement to evaluate whether or not it is suited just before determining to take the breach or resign. On the other hand, it is significant for an worker to item to the variations to their employment instantly and make a timely decision about irrespective of whether they will pursue constructive dismissal to stay clear of forfeiting the assert completely. If the staff will take way too extended, they may possibly be regarded as by the courts to have condoned or acquiesced to the new alterations and this might have a important influence on the amount of payment an personnel may possibly be awarded.

These challenges are fairly specialized in mother nature so the quicker you can get legal information, the better positioned you will be for the duration of the approach to make productive choices.

THE Second Reply

Mary Rolf, labour and work law firm, Pink Larkin, Halifax

Doing work as a total-time staff is basically distinctive from doing the job as a freelancer. A freelancer is an independent contractor, not an worker. Freelancers can have a substantial diploma of control above who they operate for and when they perform once they have built up a continuous client foundation, but it is unique from the certainty of acquiring a normal paycheque as a entire-time worker. Switching a contract from entire-time to freelance is a termination of the full-time work connection.

Businesses have wide latitude to terminate work in the course of an employee’s probationary time period. Under most provincial employment benchmarks statutes, an employer does not have to have to present detect of termination or fork out in lieu of these types of discover right up until an staff has been used for a lot more than 3 months.

Work contracts can specify a for a longer period probationary time period, but most frequently, right after 3 months, some statutory observe or spend in lieu of detect is owed. This discover is still lower, ordinarily just one 7 days depending on the provincial statute.

The bottom line is that an staff terminated all through their probationary interval has very little recourse. There can be exceptions if other things are present – for example, if there is evidence that the termination was discriminatory. Most often, however, the finest method equally basically and legally is to transfer on and appear for other get the job done.

Have a issue for our experts? Send an e-mail to [email protected] with ‘Nine to Five’ in the subject matter line. Email messages devoid of the accurate matter line might not be answered.